FAIR Stein Report banner

Home Page

FAIR Staff Contributions

Today on ImmigrationReform.com: DHS Asleep at the Switch, and Biden Advisor Doubts STEM Shortage

Dan Stein Op-Ed: Obama's Imperial Amnesty Decree

Latest Research
Looming Water Shortages in The United States

FAIR Press Release
Immigration-Driven Population Growth in the U.S. Poses Threat to Our Nation’s Water Supply

7 Principles of Immigration Reform

Resources & Links
Doing Research?
Visit some of the best immigration information sources on the internet.

Contact Us

All e-mail is subject to print, including your name. If you don't want us to publish your e-mail, or if you would like to remain anonymous, just let us know.

Add Stein Report headlines to your website or blog
Click here for instructions.

A notice to our readers: Comments on the Stein Report will only be posted when they seek to advance constructive debate and discussion, whether or not the poster agrees with the initial posting. Thank you.


 

Check out FAIR on:

Stein Report center image
October 09, 2012
 
 

The Tortured Reasoning Behind "Conservative" Amnesty Arguments


"[D]oesn't America have at least some responsibility for the presence of these workers? Absolutely our nation has some measure of responsibility for these workers coming, and then staying here. Without question, the issue of personal responsibility is and must always be a two way street. Some might argue about who was more responsible? The undocumented immigrants for coming illegally, or the U.S. for allowing then to come, stay, and work?" asks Robert Gittleson in an op-ed.

"They should, according to the law, be deported . . . However, weighing the fact that our nation was to some degree personally responsible for their illegal presence, a new law, or reform, can measure this mitigating factor in their illegal presence, and find a different path. A conservative path. What I am suggesting is that these people, having admitted to the guilt of being here illegally, should be punished, but to some lesser degree of punishment than deportation, which is life altering for them and their families."

We are in the process of archiving old comments so that they may be displayed after October 1st. New comments are being directed to the daily Stein Report post on Immigrationreform.com. Thank you to all commenters on the site - there are over 30,000 comments from the last several years that are in the process of conversion so they can be displayed on the correct pages on SteinReport.com.

To leave a comment, follow this link to today's Stein Report headlines post on ImmigrationReform.com