FAIR Stein Report banner

Home Page

FAIR Staff Contributions

The Immigrant Health Care Bill

Latest Research
State and Local Cooperation on Immigration Enforcement: ICE Access

FAIR Press Release
Despite Department of Justice’s Relentless Attack, 11th Circuit Allows Most Provisions of the Alabama Immigration Enforcement Law to Take Effect

7 Principles of Immigration Reform

Resources & Links
Doing Research?
Visit some of the best immigration information sources on the internet.

Contact Us

All e-mail is subject to print, including your name. If you don't want us to publish your e-mail, or if you would like to remain anonymous, just let us know.

Add Stein Report headlines to your website or blog
Click here for instructions.

A notice to our readers: Comments on the Stein Report will only be posted when they seek to advance constructive debate and discussion, whether or not the poster agrees with the initial posting. Thank you.


 

Check out FAIR on:

Stein Report center image

November 30, 2009



Programmer Case May Reach Supreme Court

A group of American workers, represented by FAIR's legal affiliate group IRLI (Immigration Reform Law Institute) are seeking a Supreme Court hearing on a challenge to regulations allowing foreign students a loophole to work in the U.S. The challenge centers on changes to the Optional Practical Training rules that govern how long foreign students can stay in the U.S. once they graduate. As Eweek wrote, "The Programmers Guild and other litigants fighting a 2008 Department of Homeland Security decision to extend from 12 months to 29 months the amount of time mathematics, engineering, science or technology students are allowed to work after graduation under an optional practical training program say it amounts to little more than a back-door attempt to circumvent the H-1B visa cap."

Read comments on this story



 



More Workers Hit The Streets

"Growing ranks of U.S. citizens are heading to street corners and home improvement store parking lots to find day-labor work usually done by illegal immigrants. The trend is most pronounced in regions where hot construction markets have collapsed, says Abel Valenzuela Jr., a professor of urban planning at the University of California-Los Angeles," USA Today reports. "Valenzuela estimates the proportion of U.S.-born day laborers has at least doubled since he released a report in 2006, when his research showed they made up 7% of the day-labor workforce. At that time, Valenzuela estimated 117,600 people were looking for or doing day-labor jobs on any given day."

Read comments on this story



 



Hondurans Election Ballots Cast . . . In Los Angeles

Expatriate voting in America is not new, but the contested election in Honduras drew media attention here as Hondurans in Los Angeles cast their votes for president. "Inside the Evans Community Adult School downtown, dozens of poll workers representing various political parties manned ballot stations. Across the street, protesters denounced what they called a fraudulent vote and urged a boycott," the LA Times writes. "A Census Bureau survey estimates half a million Hondurans live in the United States -- more than 40,000 of them in Los Angeles County. They have been able to vote from abroad since 2001. In addition to Los Angeles, polling stations were set up in Houston, New Orleans, Miami, Washington, D.C., and New York City."

Read comments on this story



 



Rise in Honor Killings Concerns Law Enforcement

"Muslim immigrant men have been accused of six 'honor killings' in the United States in the past two years, prompting concerns that the Muslim community and police need to do more to stop such crimes. 'There is broad support and acceptance of this idea in Islam, and we're going to see it more and more in the United States,' says Robert Spencer, who has trained FBI and military authorities on Islam and founded Jihad Watch, which monitors radical Islam," USA Today reports.

Read comments on this story



 



The Immigrant Health Care Bill

Bob Dane/Communications Director
Federation for America Immigration Reform

Patient says, "Doctor, whenever I drink coffee, I have a stabbing pain in my eye."

Doctor says, "Lady, take out the spoon before you drink."

Identifying obvious problems and dispensing common sense solutions is never the first instinct of Washington lawmakers. Our current health care reform debate - 2074 pages long - is no exception. Lost in detail, and guided by special interests, lawmakers have either forgotten or deliberately avoided asking a fundamental question that most Americans want answered: "why are there so many uninsured and who are they?" (continued in full entry)

Immigration is a major factor but this is an ignorable truth for those who want only to treat the symptom. More than one third of the uninsured in the U.S. are immigrants (legal and illegal). That same population constitutes almost half of the uninsured in California and 40% in Texas. This should be no surprise. The March 2009 Current Population Survey (CPS) reveals that 23% of the 21 million non-citizens in the U.S. were below the 100% threshold of the federal poverty level.

President Obama and key congressional leaders claim their health care bill will decrease costs and increase accessibility for 36 million uninsured in America. That remains inconclusive but what is incontrovertible - and terribly inconvenient to include in the sales pitch - is that a staggering portion of immigrants will benefit from a nationalized health care plan. It is not hard, then, to conclude that the health care reform bill is really a massive bailout for years of irresponsible immigration policy as much as it is a bill to improve health care. Truth in labeling would dictate that the Senate Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (H.R. 3590) would be more accurately described as the Immigrant Health Care Bill.

Lack of sensible controls led to the mortgage and banking crisis and subsequent bailouts; similarly, the crushing national debt has now arisen from years of poor choices about whom and how many we've been admitting into the U.S. For decades, the government has not only been turning a blind eye to illegal immigration, importing millions of guest workers, but has also been fast stamping the green cards of ever increasing numbers of the world's least skilled, least educated and most heavily government dependent. The bulk of America's legal immigrants are admitted simply because they have a relative here, not because they offer substantive skills or self reliance, common sense criteria to which most industrialized countries adhere. Sixty-nine percent of legal immigrants come to the U.S with no reported profession, occupation or job, and on average, a 9th grade education. The result has been the establishment of a permanent underclass of ill-equipped low-wage workers who pad the pockets of business but who ultimately consume more than they contribute and require public subsidies to survive.

Yes, we're all getting our lawn mowed, but the one trillion dollar health care reform bill - one third of which will subsidize indigent immigrants - doesn't really make cheap labor sound like much of a bargain anymore, not that it ever was. The gain has always been privatized and the cost socialized.

Of course, to blame legal immigrants is to miss the point. They're simply acting rationally, capitalizing on an immigration system that favors employers who profit from cheap immigrant labor. Rather, the blame rests with politicians who ignored the needs of the American worker-taxpayer and instead pandered to a constituency of cheap labor, powerful ethno-centric special interests, and Democratic party leaders wanting to increase the electorate of the needy to create instant voters. The result has been a flood of cheap foreign competition into the job markets, uninsured patients burdening hospitals, limited English proficiency students lowering educational standards in public schools and criminal aliens crowding jails.

But perhaps more prudent policies are right around the corner! After all, the same politicians whose immigration policy malfeasance created the mess are now asking America to pick up the tab for the Immigrant Health Care Bill. Surely they must be committed to avoiding the mistakes of the past.

Not even close.

At the same time this Congress is plotting how to beg, borrow and steal from the American taxpayer to subsidize immigrant health care it is simultaneously preparing the stage for a massive amnesty bill. Its impact will only perpetuate the endless cycle of chaos and exacerbate a sociological triage for resources. Special interest influences have such a stranglehold on our immigration system that not even teetering of the edge of financial meltdown appears to dissuade lawmakers from continuing self-destructive behavior.

Lowering levels of immigration and sensibly managing skilled based flows are the solutions. American workers at the lower end of the economic ladder would have less competition for jobs and see their wages rise while new immigrants would use their skills to sustain their own needs. With an unemployment rate of 10.2%, fierce competition for jobs, a continuing mortgage crisis and no end in sight to further government spending and entitlement mentality, we could all use some breathing room.

In the short run, Americans must demand that the final Senate version of the health care bill rectify immigration related problems in the House bill. Meaningful verification, closing Exchange access to illegal aliens, and maintaining the longstanding 5 year waiting period for federal benefits for most legal immigrants must be part of the package.

But the broader problems will remain and grow worse in the absence of true immigration reform that emphasizes enforcement and a reduction of the numbers. And an amnesty bill is simply out the question. The Immigrant Health Care Bill, if passed, must be a reminder that our current immigration system must vitalize our economy, not burden it.

As Thoreau said, it takes two to speak the truth - one to speak, the other to hear.

Is there any one listening?

Read comments on this story